Shakespear's HAMLET is considered by many to be the greatest play ever written in the English language, so I was looking forward to seeing the opera the 19th century composer Ambroise Thomas made from it at the Met this afternoon. It was for the most part worth seeing except for one thing. It wasn't very good.
Composed in 1868, it was last seen at the Met in1897 and it's not hard to see why.The music sounds like Verdi or Puccini on an off day, and the transformation from play to opera is clumsy and unsatisfying. To make matters worse, the production[directed by two gentlemen from France ,Patrice Caurier and Moshe Leiser] is ill-conceived and poorly designed.
The opera is generally well sung and very well conducted byLouis Langree,but instead of being truly transformed, this greatest of all plays has been forced into a medium that is not a great fit for it.
In short HAMLET as an opera does not work.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Did you know that Verdi had lots of Shakespeare in his own library? And of course he did use two of the plays for his own operas.
ReplyDelete